A possible two-fold explanation caused by fatigue from:
1. Its the one taking most of the abuse from the clutch/flywheel side of the crank; and
2. Its the one furthest away from the balancer pulley at the front of the engine
Both Rob's and Steve's cracked in the same place:
Rob Barac: "...make sure you get it crack tested before you do anything, they are prone to crack in the undercut radius on the 4th journal, if it isnt already cracked, then its happy days. Make sure you get it crack tested, they can still be cracked from factory, I have seen it before. We micro polished all of the counter weights, then nitrited the crank, after 2 years of racing it it finaly cracked so I put in a completly standard one (after getting it nitrited) and ran it another 2 years. It cracked in the same spot too, so I ended up buying an eagle crank (still a 2 litre) and ran it for another 3 years... in early 06 I went the 2.4 with the eagle bottom end and have been running it since..."